About Classic Stage Underbelly Photos Team Listen Programme Get Tickets
Penelope — An Epic New Musical Penelope — An Epic New Musical

"The wait is over for the next great show based on a Greek classic. Amusing, haunting, and deeply enchanting, Penelope transforms ancient myth into essential, breathtaking theatre."

— WhatsOnStage

"(Penelope is) ready to thrive outside the Fringe's peculiar hothouse ecology. The stunning Grace McLean's voice ripples like bronze under the smith's hammer."

— The New York Times

"The way this show's music wraps itself around the book and lyrics feels so thoroughly intimate it's nigh on sexual."

— The Washington Post

"★★★★★ Penelope is an utter triumph of songwriting and performance. [Grace McLean] combine(s) spectacular vocals and utter precision of movement into a flawless performance."

— Corr Blimey

"It's absolutely no exaggeration to say this is one of the performances of the festival. Alex Bechtel, Grace McLean and Eva Steinmetz have created something truly unique that might well just be the next big thing in mythological musicals, and is certainly this critic's pick of the fringe."

— TheaterTradge

PENELOPE waited twenty years for Odysseus to return from the Trojan War. Now she's ready to share her side of the story… but she's going to need a drink first.

Starring Broadway's Grace McLean, this contemporary chamber musical brings one of history's greatest epics to life through a Richard Rodgers Award-winning folk-pop score. Sharp, funny, and unexpectedly moving — this is Penelope's Odyssey.

Penelope production photo
Penelope at Classic Stage Company

December 10–20, 2026

136 E 13th St, New York, NY

Tickets will go on sale to:

CSC Patrons — Tuesday, September 1 at 12pm EST

Encore FlexPass Holders — Wednesday, September 2 at 12pm EST

General Public — Thursday, September 3 at 12pm EST

Penelope at Underbelly

Edinburgh Fringe

August 5–30, 2026

Underbelly, Cowgate — Belly Button

Run is complete

London, UK

September 4

Underbelly Soho Boulevard

London Tickets
Watch Penelope
Grace McLean in Penelope
Grace McLean performing in Penelope
Penelope at Ancram Center for the Arts
Full ensemble on stage in Penelope

Cast

Grace McLean

Grace McLean

as Penelope

Team

Music, Lyrics & Arrangements

Alex Bechtel

Book

Alex Bechtel, Grace McLean & Eva Steinmetz

Directed by

Eva Steinmetz

Produced by

rigor + ruckus

In association with

JGF Productions Salem Productions A+T Ventures Todd B. Rubin Dale Joan Young & James Arthur Young

The world premiere of PENELOPE was originally produced by
Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival in Garrison, NY.
Davis McCallum, Artistic Director / Kendra Ekelund, Managing Director

PENELOPE was developed, in part, through the Founders' Club Residency
as part of the Orchard Project (www.orchardproject.com)
Ari Edelson, Artistic Director

Penelope: Live from Joe's Pub

Featuring Grace McLean  ·  Released July 16, 2026

Purchase the Vinyl

A wonderfully ingratiating new musical. A kind of escape, travel without moving, storytelling in the time-stealing mode of Scheherazade. I left thinking I would gladly have listened for another day.

— The Washington Post

One of the breakout shows of this year's Fringe…atmospheric, engrossing and brimming with musicality, this is a show not to be missed.

— ReadAboutStuff

Penelope's cleverness, patience, and resilience is on full display in this highly entertaining musical.

— TheaterMania

Grace McLean

Called "phenomenal" by The New York Times, "electrifying" by The Huffington Post and a "sly-eyed musical powerhouse" by New York Magazine, Grace McLean is a multi-hyphenate actress-singer-writer-teacher. In addition to performing on Broadway (Suffs; Bad Cinderella; Natasha, Pierre & the Great Comet of 1812), Off Broadway (New Group, MCC, LCT3, Public, La MaMa, Vineyard, among others) and TV/film (The Other Two - HBO; The First Lady - Showtime), Grace also makes time for her acclaimed original music. Rolling Stone called the "avant garde pop" songs "brilliant" on her debut full length album "My Lovely Enemy." Stephen Holden of the New York Times says "Ms. McLean's voice [is] a flexible instrument with unexpected reserves of power...Behind her playful adventurousness lies a well of passion."

Grace's first original musical In The Green was commissioned and produced by Lincoln Center Theater and earned a Richard Rodgers Award for writing and a Lucille Lortel for her performance. Her work with composer Alex Bechtel and director Eva Steinmetz earned another Richard Rodgers Award for their piece Penelope. She composes music for theater (Lunar Eclise, The Apiary) and film (Marina, Our Mine - Best Score from Brooklyn Film Festival and Athens International Film Festival). Other honors include a Vivace Award, a Jonathan Larson Grant, a Lincoln Center Emerging Artist Award, and she a Broadway Women's Fund Woman to Watch. Her band has performed for the Lincoln Center American Songbook two years in a row and she toured Pakistan and Russia with the US State Department as an artistic ambassador.

Grace has taught at NYU, The New School, Northwestern, UNCC, Orange County School of the Arts, New York Youth Symphony, among others. She has developed work at Manhattan School of Music, Cincinnati Conservatory of Music, SPACE on Ryder Farm, The Orchard Project, The O'Neill, Johnny Mercer Writer's Colony at Goodspeed, The PiTCH, CAP21, The Civilians R&D Group, and MacDowell. The original cast recording for In The Green is available on Ghostlight Records. Original music "My Lovely Enemy," "Natural Disaster" and "Make Me Breakfast" are streaming now. www.gracemclean.com  @thatgracemclean

rigor + ruckus

rigor + ruckus (Producer) is a New York-based boutique theatrical producing and general management company built on a simple premise: combine operational rigor with the ruckus of creative vision to identify and develop projects that meet the current cultural moment. Founded by two-time Tony-winning producer Rachel Sussman, Tony-nominated producer and general manager Heather Shields, and Special Tony Award-winning producer Robb Nanus, r+r's recent projects include: the critically acclaimed Laura Benanti: Nobody Cares (Edinburgh Fringe, London); the Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award-winning Liberation (Broadway); and the sold-out, one-night-only concert event Rise Up, Sing Out: A Concert for the First Amendment in partnership with Jane Fonda and the Committee for the First Amendment. Upcoming: Nobody Cares US tour and Liberation in London. Several projects in development. rigor-ruckus.com

Eva Steinmetz

EVA STEINMETZ (Director + Co-Book) is a Philadelphia-based theater director and filmmaker, creating new works that straddle the ordinary and extraordinary. Most notably, she directed and co-created Poor Judge, a dance-theatre-cabaret exploring heartbreak and the Hollywood Dream, and featuring original renditions of Aimee Mann's musical catalogue (Pig Iron – 4 Barrymore Awards, including Outstanding Production of a Musical); Penelope, a contemporary chamber musical about Odysseus's waiting wife (Alex Bechtel & Grace McLean – Richard Rogers Award; 4 Barrymore nominations); and The Appointment, a musical satire skewering the hypocrisy and absurdity at the center of the American abortion debate (Lightning Rod Special – two-time NY Times Critic's Pick; Time Out NY Critics Pick; New Yorker "Best of 2023;" 6 Barrymore nominations).

Other credits include Sad Boys in Harpy Land (Alexandra Tatarsky), Art Houses (Theatre Horizon), The Caregivers (Pig Iron), Hart Island Requiem (Ty Defoe & Tidtaya Sinutoke), Wolfthicket (Lily Kind), and Krapp Hour (Anne Carson & Lightning Rod Special). Eva's short film, Marina, starring Grace McLean and Succession's Peter Friedman, received The Gotham Award and distribution through Focus Features. She was also a performer/creator in Josephine Decker's acclaimed movie, Madeline's Madeline. Eva is a Co-Artistic Director of the Pig Iron Theater Company, where she creates digital and live performances, and pilots educational and workshop-based initiatives.

Alex Bechtel

ALEX BECHTEL (Music, Lyrics, Co-Book) is a composer, actor, sound designer, writer, director, teaching artist, and multi-instrumentalist dedicated to the creation of new works of music, theatre, and musical theatre. In addition to Penelope, recent work includes: Arrangements/Music Direction for Poor Judge, an experimental dance-theatre exploration of the music of singer/songwriter Aimee Mann, with Pig Iron Theatre Company; Music & Lyrics for Lightning Rod Special's The Appointment (NYTimes, Vulture, TimeOut NY "Best of 2019" lists); People's Light & Theatre Company's Peter Panto: A Musical Panto, Alice in Wonderland: A Musical Panto, Sleeping Beauty: A Musical Panto, and Shakespeare in Love; Arden Theatre Company's The Light Princess and A Midsummer Night's Dream; and Pennsylvania Shakespeare Festival's Two Gents, Henry V, Taming of the Shrew, As You Like It, Midsummer, Much Ado, Merry Wives and Twelfth Night.

Workshop productions of his musicals Philadelphia Nocturne (2017) and Cheer Up, Dostoevsky (2018) were presented in Philadelphia. He is the creator/director/composer for the devised musical hall drama The West, which had its world premiere in 2014 at the Off-Broad Street Theatre. Bechtel is a graduate of The Pig Iron School (Inaugural Class, 2013) and The University of the Arts (BFA 2008). He has received 7 Barrymore Awards — representing recognition for Outstanding Original Music, Music Direction, Performance by an Ensemble of a Musical, and Performance by a Leading Actor in a Musical. In 2015, he was awarded an Independence Fellowship in the Arts to engage in creative study with Kentucky-based composer Rachel Grimes on new approaches to the use of music in theatre. In 2026, Bechtel was awarded the Richard Rodgers Award for Musical Theatre for Penelope, alongside co-writers Grace McLean and Eva Steinmetz. He lives in New York City. www.alexbechtel.com